This is an Apple vs oranges argument. Google will allow non-Market applications to be installed with the tick of a box, whereas with the iPhone you need to jailbreak or you are restricted to the App store. Google is only reserving the right to protect its less-savvy users within the Market but it also allows enthusiasts to do whatever they want. Not evil.
You're absolutely right. And I'm getting tired of this misinformation.
The kill switch is only for apps downloaded directly through the App Store- er, "Android Marketplace". You absolutely have the right and ability to download and install apps outside of this service, and Google and your carrier can't do a damn thing about it.
More importantly, this kill switch has several guidelines. If people bothered to read the article, they'd notice that the kill switch will only be used if the app violates the developer guidelines. This means that the app will be killed if it turns out to be malware. The kill switch is for nothing more than damage control and covering one's own ass.
The Apple app store has a vetting process where submitted apps undergo some sort of approval process, making the kill switch unnecessary for the iphone (yet they still have it in place for some reason). However, the Android marketplace has no such vetting process, and apps uploaded to the marketplace are instantly available. This creates the potential problem where some unscrupulous developers may use the massive distribution network to install evil software (malware, spyware, etc) onto many devices. The kill switch would allow Google to pull the plug on this before too many phones become infected.
Furthermore, Google has been open and forward about this kill switch- hell, they themselves announced it. Unlike Apple, they haven't tried to hide this functionality.
if cornelius is right, and google have been clear about what app behavior will make them use said kill switch, then its the direct opposite of apple, in that apple is not clear about what will make them ban a app or not.
“The HD2 is a magnificent monster. It is a hulking, intimidating, massive slab of a gadget. If you think the device looks big in photos, it's nothing compared to how it seems up close.”
Now that we've thrown 'em off the trail, use the form below to get in touch with the people at Engadget. Please fill in all of the required fields because they're required.
This is an Apple vs oranges argument. Google will allow non-Market applications to be installed with the tick of a box, whereas with the iPhone you need to jailbreak or you are restricted to the App store. Google is only reserving the right to protect its less-savvy users within the Market but it also allows enthusiasts to do whatever they want. Not evil.
Tick here: http://content.zdnet.com/2346-17932_22-240708-184.html
You're absolutely right. And I'm getting tired of this misinformation.
The kill switch is only for apps downloaded directly through the App Store- er, "Android Marketplace". You absolutely have the right and ability to download and install apps outside of this service, and Google and your carrier can't do a damn thing about it.
More importantly, this kill switch has several guidelines. If people bothered to read the article, they'd notice that the kill switch will only be used if the app violates the developer guidelines. This means that the app will be killed if it turns out to be malware. The kill switch is for nothing more than damage control and covering one's own ass.
The Apple app store has a vetting process where submitted apps undergo some sort of approval process, making the kill switch unnecessary for the iphone (yet they still have it in place for some reason). However, the Android marketplace has no such vetting process, and apps uploaded to the marketplace are instantly available. This creates the potential problem where some unscrupulous developers may use the massive distribution network to install evil software (malware, spyware, etc) onto many devices. The kill switch would allow Google to pull the plug on this before too many phones become infected.
Furthermore, Google has been open and forward about this kill switch- hell, they themselves announced it. Unlike Apple, they haven't tried to hide this functionality.
Nothing sinister here. Go back to work.
I almost forgot to mention...
Google has stated in its agreement that the kill switch will be only used if the developer distribution agreement was violated.
Apple can use their kill switch on a whim.
Big difference.
if cornelius is right, and google have been clear about what app behavior will make them use said kill switch, then its the direct opposite of apple, in that apple is not clear about what will make them ban a app or not.